Payson Real Estate Search

Payson Properties between $450,000 and $500,000 for Sale

Our website features the best real estate search for between $450,000 and $500,000 properties available in Payson and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in the Payson real estate market? Sign up for a  Payson Real Estate Market Report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Payson Properties between $450,000 and $500,000 for Sale

$475,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 7078322 MLS
Mountain Modern Charm Meets Panoramic Mogollon Rim Views Perched on one of Payson's premier view lots, this character-rich 1963 rock and adobe brick residence seamlessly blends Mid-Century architecture with authentic mountain living. Frame every season against breathtaking backdrops of Green Valley Park, Green Valley Lake, and the majestic Mogollon Rim--whether watching autumn leaves shift, crisp winter snowfalls, vibrant spring blooms, or cool summer sunsets. Upper-Level Living & Entertaining Great Room: Soaring vaulted, wood-beamed ceilings, an expansive wood-burning fireplace, and massive picture windows that flood the room with natural light. Outdoor Deck: A giant elevated deck opening directly off the main living area, perfect for year-round morning coffee, crisp alpine air, and sunset gatherings. Formal Dining: An architectural focal point wrapped in rich adobe brick texture, featuring its own cozy wood fireplace and sweeping window views. Galley Kitchen: Functional and well-appointed with wood cabinetry, a dedicated pantry, and full appliances, plus stepless rear entry access for easy grocery trips. Bedrooms & Bath: Two light-filled upstairs bedrooms, a full bathroom, and a dedicated laundry area complete with washer and dryer. Flexible Lower-Level Retreat Private Suite: A massive downstairs bedroom suite featuring a private entrance, dedicated bathroom, durable tile flooring, and a third warming fireplace--ideal for an primary suite, guest quarters, or high-yield rental space. Covered Patio: Walk directly out from the lower level to a shaded outdoor sanctuary. Exterior & Property Highlights Workroom & Parking: Enclosed single-car space currently optimized as a custom workshop (fits a compact vehicle), complemented by a seamless circular driveway off Rim View Rd. Bonus Storage: Detached backyard shed featuring vaulted overhead storage for gear, tools, and outdoor toys. Efficiency & Freedom: Fully electric home powered by a central heat pump, free from any HOA restrictions or fees. An unrepeatable piece of Payson heritage offering true four-season mountain lifestyle just minutes from town trails and lakes.

901 W Rim View Road, Payson

$450,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 7077333 MLS
COMPLETELY REMODELED • SINGLE LEVEL • NO HOA • RV ACCESS • 0.26 ACRE LOT Welcome home to a completely transformed Payson property where you can leave the projects behind and start enjoying the lifestyle you've been looking for! This beautifully remodeled 3-bedroom, 2-bath, 1,459 sq. ft. single-level home offers easy living with no interior steps, a spacious 0.26-acre lot, and no HOA. From the moment you arrive, you'll appreciate the fresh, modern transformation. The home features new interior and exterior paint, new flooring, new interior doors, new siding and trim, a new roof and fascia, new exterior lighting, new plumbing fixtures, new ceiling fans throughout, and all-new appliances--including a matching washer and dryer. The kitchen has a new backsplash, while both bathrooms have been beautifully remodeled with new fixtures and floor-to-ceiling tile. The improvements continue outside with a custom paver driveway and entryway, extensive new hardscape, new Redwood privacy fencing, and a rear ranch-style gate providing RV access. The 354 sq. ft. rear deck has been completely redone, creating an expansive outdoor living space perfect for morning coffee, summer barbecues, entertaining friends, or simply relaxing in the beautiful Payson climate. Comfort is built in with a new 3-ton central heating and air-conditioning system, five new dual-pane windows, and a new dual-pane sliding glass door. Even the crawl space has been upgraded with Water-Barrier underlayment. Need extra space? The 144 sq. ft. detached shed is far more than ordinary storage, with a new roof, stained concrete floor, power, and A/C--perfect for a workshop, hobby room, storage, or creative space. And the location makes everyday living easy. You're conveniently close to schools, shopping, dining, and the new Granite Dells Park Complex and Granite Dells Trailhead, putting recreation and everyday amenities close to home. This is the kind of home that lets you spend your time living instead of renovating. Come see the transformation for yourself--you may have just found your perfect Payson retreat!

809 E Frontier Street, Payson

$475,000
3 Beds 4 Baths 7057523 MLS
This beautiful yet affordable home right in the center of town. Quiet yet close to everything. Consists of a main home and a small apartment with a separate entrance. The main home has 2 master bedroom and 2.5 bathrooms. Custom paint and cabinets. Upgraded GE slate appliances. Free-Standing center island remains with house. Trex decking. Energy efficient. making good money) Paved parking and RV hookup and Storage. Create your own split floor plan home with room for everyone or own your investment property here in the cool Payson area. Here are a few ''extras'' we want to make sure you know about: New upper roof (all except the little piece over the front porch) - fall, 2025 Fully fenced, very large side yard Walkout basement in the back is a small apartment with 1 bedroom, a second room that consists of a kitchenette/living room combo, and a spacious bathroom. It currently has a tenant making good money. It could become an adult child's or grandparents's living quarters, a guest apartment. Private patio. Includes: Two-door 10 cu ft fridge Microwave Toaster oven Full-size sink with disposal Flip-up countertop extension Dimmered under-cabinet lighting Large pantry with bright, even lighting Range hood with ducted exhaust fan Induction cooktop can be put away in pantry or used on the patio with an ext cord Ceiling fans in bedroom and kitchen/living room 43" smart TV Flip-up coffee table Kitchen/livingroom has hard flooring, bedroom has new carpet. Unit is bermed up (half under ground) and so needs less heating/cooling Window a/c and in-wall heaters Full-sized bathroom with roomy shower and built-in linen closet North-facing pavers patio with pavers, table, chairs, umbrella, and 3-string patio lights, is shrubbery - secluded.

404 S Ponderosa Street, Payson

$479,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 7050829 MLS
Offered fully furnished and nestled along Houston Creek amid the breathtaking beauty of the Tonto National Forest, this charming 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom cabin is ready to be enjoyed from day one. Surrounded by towering pines and peaceful forest scenery, the property offers a true escape from everyday life, becoming especially serene when the seasonal creek is flowing and the sound of water carries through the property. Inside, vaulted ceilings create an open and airy atmosphere filled with natural light, while a cozy fireplace serves as the centerpiece of the living area and the perfect gathering place on cool mountain evenings. The warm, inviting layout and included furnishings make it easy to settle in and immediately begin enjoying the mountain lifestyle. Outdoor living is where thi property truly shines. The massive front deck, constructed with low-maintenance Trex decking, provides an incredible space for entertaining, relaxing, or simply taking in the sights and sounds of the surrounding forest. Enjoy your morning coffee beneath the pines, listen to Houston Creek flowing nearby, or spend peaceful evenings under a canopy of stars. The backyard is equally inviting, featuring a dedicated firepit area perfect for gathering with family and friends after a day of exploring the nearby trails, creeks, and endless recreational opportunities. Two large storage sheds provide ample space for tools, outdoor gear, recreational equipment, and seasonal storage. Fresh exterior paint adds to the home's well-maintained appearance, while its setting along Houston Creek and the Tonto National Forest makes this property truly special. Combining a fully furnished interior, vaulted ceilings, a fireplace, expansive outdoor living spaces, and the tranquility of the creek when flowing, this cabin offers a rare opportunity to own a ready-to-enjoy mountain retreat in one of Arizona's most scenic settings. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, weekend escape, or vacation rental opportunity, this property is ready to welcome you.

1957 S Moonlight Drive, Payson

$475,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 7032745 MLS
This beautiful yet affordable home right in the center of town. Quiet yet close to everything. Consists of a main home and a small apartment with a separate entrance. Create your own split floor plan home with room for everyone or own your investment property here in the cool Payson area. The main home has 2 master bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms. Energy efficient. Features include: Custom paint and cabinets Upgraded GE slate appliances Free-Standing center island Paved parking Fully fenced, HUGE side yard RV hookup and storage Trex decking New upper roof (all except the little piece over the front porch) - fall, 2025 Cold storage under house Parking for up to 6 cars (cement parking for 4 of them) Walkout basement in the back is a small apartment with 1 bedroom, a second room that consists of a kitchenette/living room combo, and a spacious bathroom. It currently has a tenant making good money. It could become an adult child's or grandparents's living quarters, a guest apartment. Private patio. Includes: Two-door 10 cu ft fridge Microwave Toaster oven Full-size sink with disposal Flip-up countertop extension Dimmered under-cabinet lighting Large pantry with bright, even lighting Range hood with ducted exhaust fan Induction cooktop can be put away in pantry or used on the patio with an ext cord Ceiling fans in bedroom and kitchen/living room 43" smart TV Flip-up coffee table Kitchen/livingroom has hard flooring, bedroom has new carpet. Unit is bermed up (half under ground) and so needs less heating/cooling Window a/c and in-wall heaters Full-sized bathroom with roomy shower and built-in linen closet North-facing pavers patio with pavers, table, chairs, umbrella, and 3-string patio lights, is shrubbery - secluded.

404 S Ponderosa Street, Payson

$499,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 7012308 MLS
• Welcome to your peaceful retreat in Ponderosa Springs! This charming three-level cabin nestled in the woods offers three bedrooms and two bathrooms, perfectly blending rustic warmth with comfortable living. The main level boasts soaring vaulted ceilings, abundant natural light from large windows, and beautiful tongue-and-groove knotty pine throughout. Other highlights include a cozy pellet stove, an open-concept family/living room flowing into the kitchen with eat-in dining and breakfast bar, a primary bedroom, a full bathroom and a convenient pantry. A large storage room with cabinetry provides ample space for organization. The second level features large windows, a propane gas heating stove, a fun bunk room for the kids/teens, a second family/living area, a full bathroom, and a laund /mud room. The third level escape is a spacious bedroom loft with privacy drapes. Every level offers stunning forest views. Outside, enjoy a covered front porch, one acre + of private wooded land, and two large sheds for extra storage - located near the Rim Lakes in Unit 23 where temperatures consistently average 30 degrees cooler than the Valley. Privately sourced well water enhances the property's self-sufficient, cabin lifestyle. Whether you're looking for a cozy Arizona A-frame cabin for the whole family or a serene getaway to create lifelong memories, this is the one! Priced competitively; seller will consider all reasonable offers.

477 S Morris Meadows --, Payson

Start Your Search

All information should be verified by the recipient and none is guaranteed as accurate by ARMLS. Copyright 2026 Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.